Row 81853

Row ID: 81853 | Dataset Entry | Axioma AXP Content Repository

Content Data

This page contains data entry 81853 from the Axioma AXP content repository. The structured data below represents the complete record for this entry.

"Someone else has kindly informed me that that number includes long term losses due to infrastructure damage."

If that's the case, we can only compare deaths directly caused by combat from both conflicts. The civilians killed in Afghanistan number 45-50,000 whilst those of the insurgents are around 55,000.

This brings the ratio in Afghanistan to under 1:1 (which includes civilians killed by all sides) whilst the ratio in Gaza is at around 2:1 (if we believe IDF PR).

This means the IDF is proportionally killing twice as many civilians as the US (et al) did in Afghanistan.

"Until then we can assume the number falls somewhere between the IDF's and Hamas' reports."

I get what you mean, and I agree about the fog of war muddying things up.

My point is that even if we take one IDF claims at face value and believe they're entirely honest and accurate, *they're still killing more than twice as many civilians per combatant than the US*.

FieldValue
text "Someone else has kindly informed me that that number includes long term losses due to infrastructure damage." If that's the case, we can only compare deaths directly caused by combat from both conflicts. The civilians killed in Afghanistan number 45-50,000 whilst those of the insurgents are around 55,000. This brings the ratio in Afghanistan to under 1:1 (which includes civilians killed by all sides) whilst the ratio in Gaza is at around 2:1 (if we believe IDF PR). This means the IDF is prop…
label r/worldnews
dataType comment
communityName r/worldnews
datetime 2024-05-24
username_encoded Z0FBQUFBQm5Lak1teHZuM0ltWEtaaGRfcXE1ckJEQUZQZVJ1bURRcHZ0dGZZcHRncG11ejBRLWVreFhoWkp0WE80dUQ1c0ZidTF0NHh0X1Noc1NTcVgyXzJDd2N4V3UtSkgxaHo3dWo2aWJlVnRTTlFGY0ZOU3M9
url_encoded Z0FBQUFBQm5Lak8zcDExR3h6clAyV0NVNTdMcXVmZzNmRFZxUnV0elV6c3BGUFFtZzk5Z3pLNFNxR1RQWmxRZHR0eTBjYkFlTGExenRzMUpxSHBvMGI2N21xWXV0dmpVN2RHeUZYSTdpZDNBSzV3OXVlTFQ2YWRBODdYQ1pVQ2V0Y0Ywdi0xazdZVnRsWkZ3MHNNY1huZG5qWXNnTEN6bVpLeDNpVG14MG0yRXM5RUtTeU5NX1djUGxzdkFSTENSV1FZdVUzZmpCZlJfdlZtWXgtSjV0OHVwZldVZWhBdXhIUT09

Raw Record

{
  "text": "\"Someone else has kindly informed me that that number includes long term losses due to infrastructure damage.\"\n\nIf that's the case, we can only compare deaths directly caused by combat from both conflicts. The civilians killed in Afghanistan number 45-50,000 whilst those of the insurgents are around 55,000.\n\nThis brings the ratio in Afghanistan to under 1:1 (which includes civilians killed by all sides) whilst the ratio in Gaza is at around 2:1 (if we believe IDF PR).\n\nThis means the IDF is proportionally killing twice as many civilians as the US (et al) did in Afghanistan.\n\n\"Until then we can assume the number falls somewhere between the IDF's and Hamas' reports.\"\n\nI get what you mean, and I agree about the fog of war muddying things up.\n\nMy point is that even if we take one IDF claims at face value and believe they're entirely honest and accurate, *they're still killing more than twice as many civilians per combatant than the US*.",
  "label": "r/worldnews",
  "dataType": "comment",
  "communityName": "r/worldnews",
  "datetime": "2024-05-24",
  "username_encoded": "Z0FBQUFBQm5Lak1teHZuM0ltWEtaaGRfcXE1ckJEQUZQZVJ1bURRcHZ0dGZZcHRncG11ejBRLWVreFhoWkp0WE80dUQ1c0ZidTF0NHh0X1Noc1NTcVgyXzJDd2N4V3UtSkgxaHo3dWo2aWJlVnRTTlFGY0ZOU3M9",
  "url_encoded": "Z0FBQUFBQm5Lak8zcDExR3h6clAyV0NVNTdMcXVmZzNmRFZxUnV0elV6c3BGUFFtZzk5Z3pLNFNxR1RQWmxRZHR0eTBjYkFlTGExenRzMUpxSHBvMGI2N21xWXV0dmpVN2RHeUZYSTdpZDNBSzV3OXVlTFQ2YWRBODdYQ1pVQ2V0Y0Ywdi0xazdZVnRsWkZ3MHNNY1huZG5qWXNnTEN6bVpLeDNpVG14MG0yRXM5RUtTeU5NX1djUGxzdkFSTENSV1FZdVUzZmpCZlJfdlZtWXgtSjV0OHVwZldVZWhBdXhIUT09"
}
Explore Dataset Explore Row

Entry Information