Row 582

Row ID: 582 | Dataset Entry | Axioma AXP Content Repository

Content Data

This page contains data entry 582 from the Axioma AXP content repository. The structured data below represents the complete record for this entry.

Thanks for your response :) I genuinely didn't think anyone would answer.

I agree that there are a lot of political matters at play. Whilst AD disputes may have origins in private company matters, I don't think that they are privately run. In China, any AD dispute goes to MOFCOM first and then is settled in the WTO if necessary. Same thing in Australia with the AD Commission. These institutions effectively support their respective private claimants/defendants, but they are public institutions and thus political in nature.

But, even if we had a strong dispute settlement body, I don't think that it would make trade policy much better. This is because of how time-consuming and costly settling the dispute actually is. If the law around AD was clearer and narrower, the imposition of a tariff would be more blatantly in breach of these provisions. The blatancy of such a breach might make private and public entities less likely to infringe these rules, thus proactively preventing ridiculous tariffs from being imposed under the guise of an AD duty (but this is up for debate).

FieldValue
text Thanks for your response :) I genuinely didn't think anyone would answer. I agree that there are a lot of political matters at play. Whilst AD disputes may have origins in private company matters, I don't think that they are privately run. In China, any AD dispute goes to MOFCOM first and then is settled in the WTO if necessary. Same thing in Australia with the AD Commission. These institutions effectively support their respective private claimants/defendants, but they are public institutions a…
label r/internationaltrade
dataType comment
communityName r/Internationaltrade
datetime 2021-04-05
username_encoded Z0FBQUFBQm5Lakx6YUFOYW5PbjNyckVaZllNNzZSLVVlYkh2UUhKbDQyMEt1cE02VWVObmZTUUxQTEh0TjdGb2pvZEFJZFNLZi0zWnRZSHc5b0Z4MUFyOFF5eDdxTWZLMmc9PQ==
url_encoded Z0FBQUFBQm5Lak9EQmMyT29sam9PblRQNjVlTnh1WnViaU5uUDdVR1JKZ3RCY1dqLTNxVWV0X0xBQ0dNTjA3LXN3TkJ6Z0pELXk5UHBCWHN5a2xfeXEybmpRRDNGdUJ6ZlVKcTZrSEZ2QkhPLVRyQ0FLSTFySzVPZEJuRm9nOGZnSEREN3hxU2xRRGlGOHBXdVFiaGh2R1JMUVl0eUdSS3BLNGdDQk9uVWlwRkFKd0VDNDhBcVZzb2ZRSDZDa3J3OER2Y292a2NCeHozYnVubE90RnF6MmpqVjFRdW1iZkZCY2VnRmVkbWJlMFlNRFpNdm9MMWIyOD0=

Raw Record

{
  "text": "Thanks for your response :) I genuinely didn't think anyone would answer.\n\nI agree that there are a lot of political matters at play. Whilst AD disputes may have origins in private company matters, I don't think that they are privately run. In China, any AD dispute goes to MOFCOM first and then is settled in the WTO if necessary. Same thing in Australia with the AD Commission. These institutions effectively support their respective private claimants/defendants, but they are public institutions and thus political in nature.\n\nBut, even if we had a strong dispute settlement body, I don't think that it would make trade policy much better. This is because of how time-consuming and costly settling the dispute actually is. If the law around AD was clearer and narrower, the imposition of a tariff would be more blatantly in breach of these provisions. The blatancy of such a breach might make private and public entities less likely to infringe these rules, thus proactively preventing ridiculous tariffs from being imposed under the guise of an AD duty (but this is up for debate).",
  "label": "r/internationaltrade",
  "dataType": "comment",
  "communityName": "r/Internationaltrade",
  "datetime": "2021-04-05",
  "username_encoded": "Z0FBQUFBQm5Lakx6YUFOYW5PbjNyckVaZllNNzZSLVVlYkh2UUhKbDQyMEt1cE02VWVObmZTUUxQTEh0TjdGb2pvZEFJZFNLZi0zWnRZSHc5b0Z4MUFyOFF5eDdxTWZLMmc9PQ==",
  "url_encoded": "Z0FBQUFBQm5Lak9EQmMyT29sam9PblRQNjVlTnh1WnViaU5uUDdVR1JKZ3RCY1dqLTNxVWV0X0xBQ0dNTjA3LXN3TkJ6Z0pELXk5UHBCWHN5a2xfeXEybmpRRDNGdUJ6ZlVKcTZrSEZ2QkhPLVRyQ0FLSTFySzVPZEJuRm9nOGZnSEREN3hxU2xRRGlGOHBXdVFiaGh2R1JMUVl0eUdSS3BLNGdDQk9uVWlwRkFKd0VDNDhBcVZzb2ZRSDZDa3J3OER2Y292a2NCeHozYnVubE90RnF6MmpqVjFRdW1iZkZCY2VnRmVkbWJlMFlNRFpNdm9MMWIyOD0="
}
Explore Dataset Explore Row

Entry Information