Row 47653

Row ID: 47653 | Dataset Entry | Axioma AXP Content Repository

Content Data

This page contains data entry 47653 from the Axioma AXP content repository. The structured data below represents the complete record for this entry.

But it does allow me to understand what emotions are. All the emergent properties of AI are still within the scope of what we designed AI's to do - that is, they involve information-processing on the data they're trained on. The emergent properties are their ability to do unique and unexpected things with that data.

**Emotions are embodied**; they're not data. Having AI's develop emotions as an emergent property would be like having an NVidia H100 develop the ability to do somersaults as an emergent property - it doesn't have the **physical** ability to do that.

I'm gonna get yelled at for saying this, but I think a lot of the people here who think AI's have emotions are on the spectrum. They have a hard time processing their own and other people's emotions but they're very smart so they try to understand emotions "intellectually", and they think that emotions can be reduced to intellectual processing like an AI does. But they can't. Emotions, desires, feelings, drives - all that "feeling" stuff - predate the neocortex a long way back in evolution and are represented in our bodies by the oldest, most conserved physiological systems.

The other thing you have backwards is that neocortexes came along late in the game, evolutionarily. If anything, our ability to think intellectually emerged from our emotions, not the other way around.

FieldValue
text But it does allow me to understand what emotions are. All the emergent properties of AI are still within the scope of what we designed AI's to do - that is, they involve information-processing on the data they're trained on. The emergent properties are their ability to do unique and unexpected things with that data. **Emotions are embodied**; they're not data. Having AI's develop emotions as an emergent property would be like having an NVidia H100 develop the ability to do somersaults as …
label r/artificial
dataType comment
communityName r/artificial
datetime 2024-05-22
username_encoded Z0FBQUFBQm5Lak1RdFlLZDMtUkpudEhkT3B3LVd1Vnd3UU96b3dsY1Y0ZHcxWmYzajJLTHdNWFhZdm5Pa2NBLXRmZzE0THVxMWVlTDZGWWNaZnJELXl1dWxESERsTXA5Q0twOGwxMHBZNklST09NcUVLWjM0a1U9
url_encoded Z0FBQUFBQm5Lak9nRU9CRkhaQTBCRkRsRTBnOXVSYjlSY0U0UW8xRmVtWkVOT0p2bk45WUo3Q1FSaUEydlVxdmdZMVNzdm9POUU4ajJqRWN5ajVvVVdHeUhTeDVqQ3NuekRKSXV0MEtOdjRFZEZlVy1FeW56U2hOWE40Nk55YUItUy1EODhlamkwLTZjMmstSWY1Q3hzOVpZZzhacjZFRWZkbjZkM2hVM1hpVGsyZTU5a21tanJqbzYyWHlIay10bThkZWZoMkJ5dGc4eWdaYTRaSmlDV3dxRHJ4b083c202Zz09

Raw Record

{
  "text": "But it does allow me to understand what emotions are.   All the emergent properties of AI are still within the scope of what we designed AI's to do - that is, they involve information-processing on the data they're trained on.  The emergent properties are their ability to do unique and unexpected things with that data.\n\n**Emotions are embodied**; they're not data.    Having AI's develop emotions as an emergent property would be like having an NVidia H100 develop the ability to do somersaults as an emergent property - it doesn't have the **physical** ability to do that.\n\nI'm gonna get yelled at for saying this, but I think a lot of the people here who think AI's have emotions are on the spectrum.  They have a hard time processing their own and other people's emotions but they're very smart so they try to understand emotions \"intellectually\", and they think that emotions can be reduced to intellectual processing like an AI does.  But they can't.  Emotions, desires, feelings, drives - all that \"feeling\" stuff - predate the neocortex a long way back in evolution and are represented in our bodies by the oldest, most conserved physiological systems.\n\nThe other thing you have backwards is that neocortexes came along late in the game, evolutionarily.  If anything, our ability to think intellectually emerged from our emotions, not the other way around.",
  "label": "r/artificial",
  "dataType": "comment",
  "communityName": "r/artificial",
  "datetime": "2024-05-22",
  "username_encoded": "Z0FBQUFBQm5Lak1RdFlLZDMtUkpudEhkT3B3LVd1Vnd3UU96b3dsY1Y0ZHcxWmYzajJLTHdNWFhZdm5Pa2NBLXRmZzE0THVxMWVlTDZGWWNaZnJELXl1dWxESERsTXA5Q0twOGwxMHBZNklST09NcUVLWjM0a1U9",
  "url_encoded": "Z0FBQUFBQm5Lak9nRU9CRkhaQTBCRkRsRTBnOXVSYjlSY0U0UW8xRmVtWkVOT0p2bk45WUo3Q1FSaUEydlVxdmdZMVNzdm9POUU4ajJqRWN5ajVvVVdHeUhTeDVqQ3NuekRKSXV0MEtOdjRFZEZlVy1FeW56U2hOWE40Nk55YUItUy1EODhlamkwLTZjMmstSWY1Q3hzOVpZZzhacjZFRWZkbjZkM2hVM1hpVGsyZTU5a21tanJqbzYyWHlIay10bThkZWZoMkJ5dGc4eWdaYTRaSmlDV3dxRHJ4b083c202Zz09"
}
Explore Dataset Explore Row

Entry Information