Row 46128

Row ID: 46128 | Dataset Entry | Axioma AXP Content Repository

Content Data

This page contains data entry 46128 from the Axioma AXP content repository. The structured data below represents the complete record for this entry.

I work in tech, manage a team of engineers, and I just don't see this on the ground. Copilot is what we have today, and it's definitely not capable of replacing an engineer. Yet.

To replace an engineer it needs business context, an ability to interface with product requirements with competence, write test plans without being aided, make roll out plans without being aided, know how to handle an incident without being aided. There is so much minutia to replacing a human I think we are still a ways off.

All of this talk feels like Elon bragging that self driving cars are around the corner. The reality is you might be able to get 50% of the way there, but then the details become more and more complex and difficult to overcome.

If AI really could replace an engineer cars would already be doing all the driving all the time because ostensibly that's a simpler, more predictable problem space.

AI is a tool, an aid, not a complete top to bottom solution. And I think that stands for the foreseeable until we see something more revolutionary than LLMs. LLMs tend to impersonate, but not embody a human.

FieldValue
text I work in tech, manage a team of engineers, and I just don't see this on the ground. Copilot is what we have today, and it's definitely not capable of replacing an engineer. Yet. To replace an engineer it needs business context, an ability to interface with product requirements with competence, write test plans without being aided, make roll out plans without being aided, know how to handle an incident without being aided. There is so much minutia to replacing a human I think we are still a way…
label r/artificial
dataType comment
communityName r/artificial
datetime 2024-05-22
username_encoded Z0FBQUFBQm5Lak1QQTk2QjBDZEhESXA0NWVrUG9GZnRydVVTR1FkV0tFZERITFNHUEdncmtTeFhIdjFjRnVZbjh5ZjZGWTN4T2FFbm9IMXdVbHhWQ01IUWZpdUc0UXlyTEJMT09iNzM0Z1Jad2tEckYtVDgwODQ9
url_encoded Z0FBQUFBQm5Lak9mT0xnd3FaQWtHd1ZsbWEtclo4WDByOFQ4Vzd3bUhrWXZyU1o5cFlNUUFsY20zUU9nLWFidTB6VXRNT1Fvd1N5MnFCZnhZeFhkX3FMWkNiZUpIaFhvNlpxVDg4NjNxVzh2VkE2eFJsRmFDR21pc1R0QVRYZ0otOWdqb3lPMlVpZXFjUC04OFlwRkI2MzdhcUtvNF9EVkxRVld3b1BZRFpsTVMwTk5aczVHSXRlZEs5UlByMmdQekpmZFBIcHhWRFlnRllzSGd1T0cycE1RQmYyaHdvd09RQT09

Raw Record

{
  "text": "I work in tech, manage a team of engineers, and I just don't see this on the ground. Copilot is what we have today, and it's definitely not capable of replacing an engineer. Yet.\n\nTo replace an engineer it needs business context, an ability to interface with product requirements with competence, write test plans without being aided, make roll out plans without being aided, know how to handle an incident without being aided. There is so much minutia to replacing a human I think we are still a ways off.\n\nAll of this talk feels like Elon bragging that self driving cars are around the corner. The reality is you might be able to get 50% of the way there, but then the details become more and more complex and difficult to overcome. \n\nIf AI really could replace an engineer cars would already be doing all the driving all the time because ostensibly that's a simpler, more predictable problem space.\n\nAI is a tool, an aid, not a complete top to bottom solution. And I think that stands for the foreseeable until we see something more revolutionary than LLMs. LLMs tend to impersonate, but not embody a human.",
  "label": "r/artificial",
  "dataType": "comment",
  "communityName": "r/artificial",
  "datetime": "2024-05-22",
  "username_encoded": "Z0FBQUFBQm5Lak1QQTk2QjBDZEhESXA0NWVrUG9GZnRydVVTR1FkV0tFZERITFNHUEdncmtTeFhIdjFjRnVZbjh5ZjZGWTN4T2FFbm9IMXdVbHhWQ01IUWZpdUc0UXlyTEJMT09iNzM0Z1Jad2tEckYtVDgwODQ9",
  "url_encoded": "Z0FBQUFBQm5Lak9mT0xnd3FaQWtHd1ZsbWEtclo4WDByOFQ4Vzd3bUhrWXZyU1o5cFlNUUFsY20zUU9nLWFidTB6VXRNT1Fvd1N5MnFCZnhZeFhkX3FMWkNiZUpIaFhvNlpxVDg4NjNxVzh2VkE2eFJsRmFDR21pc1R0QVRYZ0otOWdqb3lPMlVpZXFjUC04OFlwRkI2MzdhcUtvNF9EVkxRVld3b1BZRFpsTVMwTk5aczVHSXRlZEs5UlByMmdQekpmZFBIcHhWRFlnRllzSGd1T0cycE1RQmYyaHdvd09RQT09"
}
Explore Dataset Explore Row

Entry Information