Row 45995

Row ID: 45995 | Dataset Entry | Axioma AXP Content Repository

Content Data

This page contains data entry 45995 from the Axioma AXP content repository. The structured data below represents the complete record for this entry.

You're not wrong about it being goofy, but that's not quite it.

The Super AI (in the future) cannot do anything in the present to bring about its existence (because it's in the future). Ergo, the only thing it can do to encourage the creation of itself is to ensure that only people who helped build it get to live peacefully in the future (by torturing anyone who didn't help).

It's alluring to certain thinkers because of its achronological reasoning, but ultimately... any AI that exists would already exist, and would not be incentivized to create incentives that lead to its existence. Like, duh. It's the kind of argument that only makes a certain kind of sense in a certain framework, but falls apart quickly outside of thought experiment land.

FieldValue
text You're not wrong about it being goofy, but that's not quite it. The Super AI (in the future) cannot do anything in the present to bring about its existence (because it's in the future). Ergo, the only thing it can do to encourage the creation of itself is to ensure that only people who helped build it get to live peacefully in the future (by torturing anyone who didn't help). It's alluring to certain thinkers because of its achronological reasoning, but ultimately... any AI that exists would …
label r/technology
dataType comment
communityName r/technology
datetime 2024-05-22
username_encoded Z0FBQUFBQm5Lak1QSXFxLVNlVHhWUzBYdnhBSTNZWVQ0ZC1VbVZYS253eXZNa3J2ZXNjZGU0T0FTb2RTSXp6SjZoTEw3WGtOQlE2UjJxSHN1LVQwWHJUdEZ2bHc1a0JSUUlZSmQyVkZNNjc0d3otUE5kMEJPak09
url_encoded Z0FBQUFBQm5Lak9mTHhpdGFYTkY0ekstZW5rZXFNZlBDMUtWR2dmVDU1MGJQZmxPV051elpTZ2twR1hudTItbHN5czFWak51dnl5RmktVDNqN0g0Mk45ek1GVENxN0hGZkRZaDVfaEFuOTV2ejJVQmZsMElYUGxxczJxT2J2VGNMUnFHc19iNThmMGdRamhGbzhHS3hUbXVCekpWQ0NjYXNGdUE2S2F0aXF1cGR1REtLbUkwVG9aczRpY1dlX3BOZkMxSkM1YUt3VzlxelFqN1dyaklzV2htdTRxYnhIU3ZWZz09

Raw Record

{
  "text": "You're not wrong about it being goofy, but that's not quite it. \n\nThe Super AI (in the future) cannot do anything in the present to bring about its existence (because it's in the future). Ergo, the only thing it can do to encourage the creation of itself is to ensure that only people who helped build it get to live peacefully in the future (by torturing anyone who didn't help).\n\nIt's alluring to certain thinkers because of its achronological reasoning, but ultimately... any AI that exists would already exist, and would not be incentivized to create incentives that lead to its existence. Like, duh. It's the kind of argument that only makes a certain kind of sense in a certain framework, but falls apart quickly outside of thought experiment land.",
  "label": "r/technology",
  "dataType": "comment",
  "communityName": "r/technology",
  "datetime": "2024-05-22",
  "username_encoded": "Z0FBQUFBQm5Lak1QSXFxLVNlVHhWUzBYdnhBSTNZWVQ0ZC1VbVZYS253eXZNa3J2ZXNjZGU0T0FTb2RTSXp6SjZoTEw3WGtOQlE2UjJxSHN1LVQwWHJUdEZ2bHc1a0JSUUlZSmQyVkZNNjc0d3otUE5kMEJPak09",
  "url_encoded": "Z0FBQUFBQm5Lak9mTHhpdGFYTkY0ekstZW5rZXFNZlBDMUtWR2dmVDU1MGJQZmxPV051elpTZ2twR1hudTItbHN5czFWak51dnl5RmktVDNqN0g0Mk45ek1GVENxN0hGZkRZaDVfaEFuOTV2ejJVQmZsMElYUGxxczJxT2J2VGNMUnFHc19iNThmMGdRamhGbzhHS3hUbXVCekpWQ0NjYXNGdUE2S2F0aXF1cGR1REtLbUkwVG9aczRpY1dlX3BOZkMxSkM1YUt3VzlxelFqN1dyaklzV2htdTRxYnhIU3ZWZz09"
}
Explore Dataset Explore Row

Entry Information