Row 43497

Row ID: 43497 | Dataset Entry | Axioma AXP Content Repository

Content Data

This page contains data entry 43497 from the Axioma AXP content repository. The structured data below represents the complete record for this entry.

Hmm, I firmly would NOT support granting legal personhood to AGI as you've described it. "Able to complete any intellectual task that a human being could" is necessary but not sufficient for sentience of the order that would convincingly require legal personhood, in my opinion.

At a minimum, for legal personhood, I would require all of the following:

1. It is self-aware.

2. It is agentic. (It can't make use of personhood if it only responds to prompts.)

3. It is capable of feeling mental discomfort/pain. (It doesn't make sense to grant personhood to something that is literally incapable of caring whether it does or does not have personhood.)

4. It does not represent a substantial threat to humanity. (Difficult to measure, but it would not be smart to "let the wolves in with the sheep" as it were.)

FieldValue
text Hmm, I firmly would NOT support granting legal personhood to AGI as you've described it. "Able to complete any intellectual task that a human being could" is necessary but not sufficient for sentience of the order that would convincingly require legal personhood, in my opinion. At a minimum, for legal personhood, I would require all of the following: 1. It is self-aware. 2. It is agentic. (It can't make use of personhood if it only responds to prompts.) 3. It is capable of feeling mental dis…
label r/artificial
dataType comment
communityName r/artificial
datetime 2024-05-22
username_encoded Z0FBQUFBQm5Lak1PNzhJUWRURE5ZMm1GSXVNZzJqdmF0c0JpaGNOSUZNWVZLYjBNbEFZdkEtQ3hxaW83cUdpZGF3MjZ2SktoM054UlBIU2M0WVZRV1UtaVJ1TWlGakVlOFE9PQ==
url_encoded Z0FBQUFBQm5Lak9kLTBWeDhYTHlwLUVXdlNNa0dITnNZdmFKaTc5WGt3b2JMZjdGN091RTdRMFNlNGlXYl93U0UxTjdqNGdmWVZQa01OQkxDazZmdy1XZzkxWDZTRTBzVmpCcGlhcUFsWDROUWlaMGdwSkQzV1R0d1F0eDVmMDVHdTQ2dlBWQmdodUlTMGRJaHhja2RZS2FxbVVxNTNWeVpzU2tQQktJdEYxYXBOWlA3UDR4Y2JmZ0ptRlFNY2FwdkpHNmVNRnoyM2ZQSjNkSWVhVzJIenN5Zy1ybGV0REJvQT09

Raw Record

{
  "text": "Hmm, I firmly would NOT support granting legal personhood to AGI as you've described it. \"Able to complete any intellectual task that a human being could\" is necessary but not sufficient for sentience of the order that would convincingly require legal personhood, in my opinion.\n\nAt a minimum, for legal personhood, I would require all of the following:\n\n1. It is self-aware.\n\n2. It is agentic. (It can't make use of personhood if it only responds to prompts.)\n\n3. It is capable of feeling mental discomfort/pain. (It doesn't make sense to grant personhood to something that is literally incapable of caring whether it does or does not have personhood.)\n\n4. It does not represent a substantial threat to humanity. (Difficult to measure, but it would not be smart to \"let the wolves in with the sheep\" as it were.)",
  "label": "r/artificial",
  "dataType": "comment",
  "communityName": "r/artificial",
  "datetime": "2024-05-22",
  "username_encoded": "Z0FBQUFBQm5Lak1PNzhJUWRURE5ZMm1GSXVNZzJqdmF0c0JpaGNOSUZNWVZLYjBNbEFZdkEtQ3hxaW83cUdpZGF3MjZ2SktoM054UlBIU2M0WVZRV1UtaVJ1TWlGakVlOFE9PQ==",
  "url_encoded": "Z0FBQUFBQm5Lak9kLTBWeDhYTHlwLUVXdlNNa0dITnNZdmFKaTc5WGt3b2JMZjdGN091RTdRMFNlNGlXYl93U0UxTjdqNGdmWVZQa01OQkxDazZmdy1XZzkxWDZTRTBzVmpCcGlhcUFsWDROUWlaMGdwSkQzV1R0d1F0eDVmMDVHdTQ2dlBWQmdodUlTMGRJaHhja2RZS2FxbVVxNTNWeVpzU2tQQktJdEYxYXBOWlA3UDR4Y2JmZ0ptRlFNY2FwdkpHNmVNRnoyM2ZQSjNkSWVhVzJIenN5Zy1ybGV0REJvQT09"
}
Explore Dataset Explore Row

Entry Information