Row 42959

Row ID: 42959 | Dataset Entry | Axioma AXP Content Repository

Content Data

This page contains data entry 42959 from the Axioma AXP content repository. The structured data below represents the complete record for this entry.

Why are you so defensive? It's weird? Are you some superfan or do you just not understand the legal situation? Now resorting to naming Wiki-fallacies too? How about the fallacy of false equivalence, comparing cases with paid musical impersonators to young women who happen to sound similar?

No, it's not illegal to hire someone with a "broadly similar voice" if you're not able to use the same actor. Otherwise, they would never be able to hire any voice female actor of Scarlett's age. That's obviously ridiculous, and you know it. It would be illegal to hire an actual impersonator who deliberately affected all the mannerisms of a voice. How many Scarjo impersonators do you know?

It hasn't been marketed as 'Her' either. The only reference to the movie (AFAIK) is a single tweet made from Altman's account (not OpenAI0 with the word her. That isn't marketing, obviously. That's an off the cuff comparison by an employee that he's probably kicking himself for.

Yes, many people thought it did (partly because of the informal content of what she was saying rather than the timbre of her voice), and many others didn't. Sorry, but you'd need a lot more than that to get the case won.

Comparing spectograms is what I'm getting at. At what point do you say 'Yes that's similar enough to constitute an impersonation?' You need a logical and repeatable yardstick, and not some trust-fund Hollywood actor and her fans saying it's the same.

FieldValue
text Why are you so defensive? It's weird? Are you some superfan or do you just not understand the legal situation? Now resorting to naming Wiki-fallacies too? How about the fallacy of false equivalence, comparing cases with paid musical impersonators to young women who happen to sound similar? No, it's not illegal to hire someone with a "broadly similar voice" if you're not able to use the same actor. Otherwise, they would never be able to hire any voice female actor of Scarlett's age. That's…
label r/openai
dataType comment
communityName r/OpenAI
datetime 2024-05-22
username_encoded Z0FBQUFBQm5Lak1OSTBzSHd4bDk2TWJ5ak5MWXlDeEVta2FRektkQXhPMkEtbmV5YkpxdnJ3YlRvRWI5eHJudEZyODJYN2hudW9YUWNxYWFrX0VWSURjZW1Ud3BfTHpTMnc9PQ==
url_encoded Z0FBQUFBQm5Lak9kM0xfamVvcF9FM0JINmRFZ3R3VFJNcGNkdEN5RUJpTk55UE5Fa0hxT0ZRU3RrbkUxdHJ1cWtoXzRrTUtzT1A2eFoxSHVkSlFoQ0FfUWdSbl9LV2YxZFdVM253bFh5dFR0aF85dnN4cTI3b1F4RTNYWkhLcHRQUHJrdTl1NlZta0FwQVNBS2xxakFOQlBLOFVCbmFVeXBwa1pyOGs5NDA4My1WUXZzTDAtM29HaC1laUZOY1BpMXExajBlVWJ3djl3

Raw Record

{
  "text": "Why are you so defensive?  It's weird?  Are you some superfan or do you just not understand the legal situation?  Now resorting to naming Wiki-fallacies too?  How about the fallacy of false equivalence, comparing cases with paid musical impersonators to young women who happen to sound similar?\n\nNo, it's not illegal to hire someone with a \"broadly similar voice\" if you're not able to use the same actor.  Otherwise, they would never be able to hire any voice female actor of Scarlett's age.  That's obviously ridiculous, and you know it.  It would be illegal to hire an actual impersonator who deliberately affected all the mannerisms of a voice.  How many Scarjo impersonators do you know?  \n\nIt hasn't been marketed as 'Her' either.  The only reference to the movie (AFAIK) is a single tweet made from Altman's account (not OpenAI0 with the word her.  That isn't marketing, obviously.  That's an off the cuff comparison by an employee that he's probably kicking himself for. \n\nYes, many people thought it did (partly because of the informal content of what she was saying rather than the timbre of her voice), and many others didn't.  Sorry, but you'd need a lot more than that to get the case won.\n\nComparing spectograms is what I'm getting at.  At what point do you say 'Yes that's similar enough to constitute an impersonation?'  You need a logical and repeatable yardstick, and not some trust-fund Hollywood actor and her fans saying it's the same.",
  "label": "r/openai",
  "dataType": "comment",
  "communityName": "r/OpenAI",
  "datetime": "2024-05-22",
  "username_encoded": "Z0FBQUFBQm5Lak1OSTBzSHd4bDk2TWJ5ak5MWXlDeEVta2FRektkQXhPMkEtbmV5YkpxdnJ3YlRvRWI5eHJudEZyODJYN2hudW9YUWNxYWFrX0VWSURjZW1Ud3BfTHpTMnc9PQ==",
  "url_encoded": "Z0FBQUFBQm5Lak9kM0xfamVvcF9FM0JINmRFZ3R3VFJNcGNkdEN5RUJpTk55UE5Fa0hxT0ZRU3RrbkUxdHJ1cWtoXzRrTUtzT1A2eFoxSHVkSlFoQ0FfUWdSbl9LV2YxZFdVM253bFh5dFR0aF85dnN4cTI3b1F4RTNYWkhLcHRQUHJrdTl1NlZta0FwQVNBS2xxakFOQlBLOFVCbmFVeXBwa1pyOGs5NDA4My1WUXZzTDAtM29HaC1laUZOY1BpMXExajBlVWJ3djl3"
}
Explore Dataset Explore Row

Entry Information