Row 39983

Row ID: 39983 | Dataset Entry | Axioma AXP Content Repository

Content Data

This page contains data entry 39983 from the Axioma AXP content repository. The structured data below represents the complete record for this entry.

Potentially return the bonus to giving tips?

**I know, I know, this sounds a bit ridiculous given we just removed them.**

However, the sub seems to be going through some significant evolution.

**Assuming the proposal to switch to a Comment/Tip2Vote is successful** we will be left with a double up in rewards.

If tips are also considered upvotes, we will then have 540k DONUTs allocated for posts, and 77k DONUTs allocated for receiving tips... but this will effectively be the same thing and actually **make "post upvotes" a total allocation of 617k donuts.**

It seems redundant to then have tips rewards for receiving tips when the exact same command is for post upvotes.

# Idea

What if, we take those 77k donuts for receiving tips, and reverse them into 77k donuts for giving tips with two changes.

1) Tipping comments will also be eligible.

2) ONLY tips of 1 or greater will be eligible.

Now, I'm absolutely confident this can't be gamed too much because with only 77k DONUTs, there will highly likely be over 77k tips handed out, resulting in a ratio of <1. With only tips above 1 eligible for rewards, this should mean it can not be gamed to award others to receive more donuts yourself.

Rather than being farmed, the way it used to be, at most it would only serve as a small reimbursement. This might help encourage some users to provide tips on those quality comments.

I might be off the mark with this one, but given the sub seems to be going through some significant changes, I thought I would open this discussion up - in particular seeking the opinions of the mods who are supporting the tip2comment proposal.

**Either way I think the 77k DONUT for receiving tips should be re-allocated.** IF the comment2Upvote proposal goes ahead.

* Reverse to giving tips again? * Add to liquidity incentives? * Create a method to reward NOMINATED comments? * Re-allocate into treasury funds?

What do you think?

FieldValue
text Potentially return the bonus to giving tips? **I know, I know, this sounds a bit ridiculous given we just removed them.** However, the sub seems to be going through some significant evolution. **Assuming the proposal to switch to a Comment/Tip2Vote is successful** we will be left with a double up in rewards. If tips are also considered upvotes, we will then have 540k DONUTs allocated for posts, and 77k DONUTs allocated for receiving tips... but this will effectively be the same thing and act…
label r/ethtrader
dataType post
communityName r/ethtrader
datetime 2024-05-22
username_encoded Z0FBQUFBQm5Lak1MdkdKNnZ5YjFXRjNzNmNWVmFJOGxlUlMwQ016YTBiMk82UGxVT1AwNlpuZ280SG9GdVVKZmY0OGdTb0V2QU9saGpEZGNxTlZOMk5OQzZVMlc1TE1raGc9PQ==
url_encoded Z0FBQUFBQm5Lak9idW9PRDJ6aDI5c090WGYtREhYb3pYcm5QdFNOc3ljVzRWMXBUSWR6b1NoeHFVU3BfWmhwWmxCbHJuYm5wSmRoaDlLNzN1cjVlMElZWndmUzNJZTVLcjhNa3hxM1lCMVF3RWFQZjhVSlFZZFJiamh1aXBUMmpRNjBEU2dPMmJ2TndadTNrUktXVWMybVctZm4zVi1BSHlXZzU4aDBVU2x4MlRmazIyLW8wZ1dJLTl6eDZNSjhuZEVTSkozWWZRa2kyajF3V3BxUXRqZHV0UjZMM3BseWh0dz09

Raw Record

{
  "text": "Potentially return the bonus to giving tips?\n\n**I know, I know, this sounds a bit ridiculous given we just removed them.**\n\nHowever, the sub seems to be going through some significant evolution.\n\n**Assuming the proposal to switch to a Comment/Tip2Vote is successful** we will be left with a double up in rewards.\n\nIf tips are also considered upvotes, we will then have 540k DONUTs allocated for posts, and 77k DONUTs allocated for receiving tips... but this will effectively be the same thing and actually **make \"post upvotes\" a total allocation of 617k donuts.**\n\nIt seems redundant to then have tips rewards for receiving tips when the exact same command is for post upvotes.\n\n# Idea\n\nWhat if, we take those 77k donuts for receiving tips, and reverse them into 77k donuts for giving tips with two changes.\n\n1) Tipping comments will also be eligible.\n\n2) ONLY tips of 1 or greater will be eligible.\n\nNow, I'm absolutely confident this can't be gamed too much because with only 77k DONUTs, there will highly likely be over 77k tips handed out, resulting in a ratio of <1. With only tips above 1 eligible for rewards, this should mean it can not be gamed to award others to receive more donuts yourself.\n\nRather than being farmed, the way it used to be, at most it would only serve as a small reimbursement. This might help encourage some users to provide tips on those quality comments.\n\nI might be off the mark with this one, but given the sub seems to be going through some significant changes, I thought I would open this discussion up - in particular seeking the opinions of the mods who are supporting the tip2comment proposal.\n\n**Either way I think the 77k DONUT for receiving tips should be re-allocated.** IF the comment2Upvote proposal goes ahead.\n\n* Reverse to giving tips again? \n* Add to liquidity incentives? \n* Create a method to reward NOMINATED comments?\n* Re-allocate into treasury funds?\n\nWhat do you think?",
  "label": "r/ethtrader",
  "dataType": "post",
  "communityName": "r/ethtrader",
  "datetime": "2024-05-22",
  "username_encoded": "Z0FBQUFBQm5Lak1MdkdKNnZ5YjFXRjNzNmNWVmFJOGxlUlMwQ016YTBiMk82UGxVT1AwNlpuZ280SG9GdVVKZmY0OGdTb0V2QU9saGpEZGNxTlZOMk5OQzZVMlc1TE1raGc9PQ==",
  "url_encoded": "Z0FBQUFBQm5Lak9idW9PRDJ6aDI5c090WGYtREhYb3pYcm5QdFNOc3ljVzRWMXBUSWR6b1NoeHFVU3BfWmhwWmxCbHJuYm5wSmRoaDlLNzN1cjVlMElZWndmUzNJZTVLcjhNa3hxM1lCMVF3RWFQZjhVSlFZZFJiamh1aXBUMmpRNjBEU2dPMmJ2TndadTNrUktXVWMybVctZm4zVi1BSHlXZzU4aDBVU2x4MlRmazIyLW8wZ1dJLTl6eDZNSjhuZEVTSkozWWZRa2kyajF3V3BxUXRqZHV0UjZMM3BseWh0dz09"
}
Explore Dataset Explore Row

Entry Information