Row 3332

Row ID: 3332 | Dataset Entry | Axioma AXP Content Repository

Content Data

This page contains data entry 3332 from the Axioma AXP content repository. The structured data below represents the complete record for this entry.

These are well-thought out positions. Do you work in the ML field, a Google employee perhaps?

All that history may be true, but people have choices. If you're on the wrong road, you can still turn back. Geoffrey Hinton did, and so did Yoshua Bengio. By continuing on the present path, let's be clear that Demmis and co are \*deciding\* to advance capabilities.

Additionally, I recognize the race dynamics are difficult, similar to a societal problem like global warming.

However what I find so disagreeable about your take is that you're effectively positioning Demmis Hasabis and leading labs that aren't OpenAI as moderates. Saying they are moderates because they entertain AI existential risk issues is just frame control and completely irresponsible.

You would never enter a plane that had a 10% chance of crashing. Likewise, if you are working on a project which you believe has a 10% chance of ending the world in the next 20 years (Geoffrey Hinton's latest pdoom), that is reckless and needs to be stopped!

I do think some of the safety work done at the labs is good i.e. mechanistic interpretability, the supersafety team that OpenAI is starting, the safety research that's likely happening under the auspices of DeepMind.

Just look at what Geoffrey Hinton, Yoshua Bengio and Max Tegmark and so on are doing. They are calling for regulation to minimize the existential risk all across the world. That is what someone in industry should be doing. The folks at the leading AI labs have twisted their minds around a logic, like yours, that somehow accelerating this tech helps the cause.

What they're doing is simply not okay. They're gambling with the lives of us and loved ones. It should be illegal.

FieldValue
text These are well-thought out positions. Do you work in the ML field, a Google employee perhaps? All that history may be true, but people have choices. If you're on the wrong road, you can still turn back. Geoffrey Hinton did, and so did Yoshua Bengio. By continuing on the present path, let's be clear that Demmis and co are \*deciding\* to advance capabilities. Additionally, I recognize the race dynamics are difficult, similar to a societal problem like global warming. However what I find so di…
label r/deepmind
dataType comment
communityName r/deepmind
datetime 2024-02-28
username_encoded Z0FBQUFBQm5LakwxT1R1ZUthRnM0V2tzZno1Vy16UlR1TVdLelFXdnBxNk9PMFpUVi1ScW1kdDhvcjRUVjlJWEVScjFKeFVkUmRqM2lOZlg5UkNvcU83WmhZT1NFNVAwbFE9PQ==
url_encoded Z0FBQUFBQm5Lak9FQXljcFlZNzZ3ZDVKZlkxcVNaYW11Ql81Q1dnbWRTUlh3c0FUWmk5ek5JTEVWbER6Mktpczc3VmdWY1hHeGVrdU8zdmxmYW1LNTdMU3lzSWUtVVE2UnNZQndzZG1QN1FvZ3FybkxmdDhkUUJOQWxoU1NMRF8wLTVHQTM5OFFPaG83QnR4b3IxNWNTeU4xTXN4NjNVRHBHREd6YzVYZ25fMGhJZ3JWc1VPM2FZcE8zcGJDdUprZHhyWGN6b3cybjR3

Raw Record

{
  "text": "These are well-thought out positions. Do you work in the ML field, a Google employee perhaps?\n\nAll that history may be true, but people have choices. If you're on the wrong road, you can still turn back. Geoffrey Hinton did, and so did Yoshua Bengio. By continuing on the present path, let's be clear that Demmis and co are \\*deciding\\* to advance capabilities.\n\nAdditionally, I recognize the race dynamics are difficult, similar to a societal problem like global warming. \n\nHowever what I find so disagreeable about your take is that you're effectively positioning Demmis Hasabis and leading labs that aren't OpenAI as moderates. Saying they are moderates because they entertain AI existential risk issues is just frame control and completely irresponsible.\n\nYou would never enter a plane that had a 10% chance of crashing. Likewise, if you are working on a project which you believe has a 10% chance of ending the world in the next 20 years (Geoffrey Hinton's latest pdoom), that is reckless and needs to be stopped!\n\nI do think some of the safety work done at the labs is good i.e. mechanistic interpretability, the supersafety team that OpenAI is starting, the safety research that's likely happening under the auspices of DeepMind.\n\nJust look at what Geoffrey Hinton, Yoshua Bengio and Max Tegmark and so on are doing. They are calling for regulation to minimize the existential risk all across the world. That is what someone in industry should be doing. The folks at the leading AI labs have twisted their minds around a logic, like yours, that somehow accelerating this tech helps the cause.\n\nWhat they're doing is simply not okay. They're gambling with the lives of us and loved ones. It should be illegal.",
  "label": "r/deepmind",
  "dataType": "comment",
  "communityName": "r/deepmind",
  "datetime": "2024-02-28",
  "username_encoded": "Z0FBQUFBQm5LakwxT1R1ZUthRnM0V2tzZno1Vy16UlR1TVdLelFXdnBxNk9PMFpUVi1ScW1kdDhvcjRUVjlJWEVScjFKeFVkUmRqM2lOZlg5UkNvcU83WmhZT1NFNVAwbFE9PQ==",
  "url_encoded": "Z0FBQUFBQm5Lak9FQXljcFlZNzZ3ZDVKZlkxcVNaYW11Ql81Q1dnbWRTUlh3c0FUWmk5ek5JTEVWbER6Mktpczc3VmdWY1hHeGVrdU8zdmxmYW1LNTdMU3lzSWUtVVE2UnNZQndzZG1QN1FvZ3FybkxmdDhkUUJOQWxoU1NMRF8wLTVHQTM5OFFPaG83QnR4b3IxNWNTeU4xTXN4NjNVRHBHREd6YzVYZ25fMGhJZ3JWc1VPM2FZcE8zcGJDdUprZHhyWGN6b3cybjR3"
}
Explore Dataset Explore Row

Entry Information