Row 27792

Row ID: 27792 | Dataset Entry | Axioma AXP Content Repository

Content Data

This page contains data entry 27792 from the Axioma AXP content repository. The structured data below represents the complete record for this entry.

It's linked from the article. I just skimmed through it. It's summarizing meta-analyses which compare people eating vegetarian/vegan diets to everyone else. They specifically exclude studies that mention other diets like the Mediterranean diet. They specifically exclude interventional studies that might answer causal questions. So it's asking a question I doubt many people interested in health actually care about: are people eating vegetarian or vegan diets healthier than the average non-vegetarian? Unsurprisingly, the answer is yes.

Are they healthier than diets which include meat and are designed to be healthy or have research to back them like Mediterranean, DASH, MIND, etc.? Not addressed by the study. Are they healthier than high meat diets like keto, paleo, etc.? Not addressed by the study. If you switch people to a vegetarian/vegan diet, does that make them healthier than doing nothing or switching to another diet? Not addressed by the study.

I'm sure the study is competently done, but it's hard for me to imagine why it was written. It seems like a forgone conclusion to a useless question, specifically designed to use only the weakest tier of evidence in nutritional epidemiology.

FieldValue
text It's linked from the article. I just skimmed through it. It's summarizing meta-analyses which compare people eating vegetarian/vegan diets to everyone else. They specifically exclude studies that mention other diets like the Mediterranean diet. They specifically exclude interventional studies that might answer causal questions. So it's asking a question I doubt many people interested in health actually care about: are people eating vegetarian or vegan diets healthier than the average non-vegetar…
label r/health
dataType comment
communityName r/Health
datetime 2024-05-21
username_encoded Z0FBQUFBQm5Lak1FbU5rNzJUUGpndVVqOVFteTBSczh0aE9OMXlIUjRvMUdXV09wVzFKbkhQcTcwb1VUeHBGcUI0YVFOcVo1TGRsOXRNMUJHSDEtR2lFbm5wSk1nLXVKX3BtdENRUG1ZLUhnOHBhUWFwOTZaRFU9
url_encoded Z0FBQUFBQm5Lak9UcXNtVnlDUDVtZTRMZjF3dlppZHpmeGpmVzVHZHE2dHZPUmk0S0UtMWViY1VFS1JZQ0VkZjhjMkduTm1RRURMQ1pQdDdEWlE5WExLaUVSYjA5eTkxUnYteE1zU01aLUVMdGxFdnVrTGMtSHpQZDJCdXo3WmtSdnNGMkYzcjh6STFOOWZEUXAxQXg3U2lnLWpqbVJPQjQxSWxPWmQyb2M3Yk50WkV6cE9iTi1hcVV5b3dRTGdDZXVjbDIwcE1iQUhuQXdPTjNPa25pcnREemxreGxsQ2NDUT09

Raw Record

{
  "text": "It's linked from the article. I just skimmed through it. It's summarizing meta-analyses which compare people eating vegetarian/vegan diets to everyone else. They specifically exclude studies that mention other diets like the Mediterranean diet. They specifically exclude interventional studies that might answer causal questions. So it's asking a question I doubt many people interested in health actually care about: are people eating vegetarian or vegan diets healthier than the average non-vegetarian? Unsurprisingly, the answer is yes. \n\nAre they healthier than diets which include meat and are designed to be healthy or have research to back them like Mediterranean, DASH, MIND, etc.? Not addressed by the study. Are they healthier than high meat diets like keto, paleo, etc.? Not addressed by the study. If you switch people to a vegetarian/vegan diet, does that make them healthier than doing nothing or switching to another diet? Not addressed by the study.\n\nI'm sure the study is competently done, but it's hard for me to imagine why it was written. It seems like a forgone conclusion to a useless question, specifically designed to use only the weakest tier of evidence in nutritional epidemiology.",
  "label": "r/health",
  "dataType": "comment",
  "communityName": "r/Health",
  "datetime": "2024-05-21",
  "username_encoded": "Z0FBQUFBQm5Lak1FbU5rNzJUUGpndVVqOVFteTBSczh0aE9OMXlIUjRvMUdXV09wVzFKbkhQcTcwb1VUeHBGcUI0YVFOcVo1TGRsOXRNMUJHSDEtR2lFbm5wSk1nLXVKX3BtdENRUG1ZLUhnOHBhUWFwOTZaRFU9",
  "url_encoded": "Z0FBQUFBQm5Lak9UcXNtVnlDUDVtZTRMZjF3dlppZHpmeGpmVzVHZHE2dHZPUmk0S0UtMWViY1VFS1JZQ0VkZjhjMkduTm1RRURMQ1pQdDdEWlE5WExLaUVSYjA5eTkxUnYteE1zU01aLUVMdGxFdnVrTGMtSHpQZDJCdXo3WmtSdnNGMkYzcjh6STFOOWZEUXAxQXg3U2lnLWpqbVJPQjQxSWxPWmQyb2M3Yk50WkV6cE9iTi1hcVV5b3dRTGdDZXVjbDIwcE1iQUhuQXdPTjNPa25pcnREemxreGxsQ2NDUT09"
}
Explore Dataset Explore Row

Entry Information