Row 1914

Row ID: 1914 | Dataset Entry | Axioma AXP Content Repository

Content Data

This page contains data entry 1914 from the Axioma AXP content repository. The structured data below represents the complete record for this entry.

For example, [performance enhancing drug scandals are a perennial problem in sports](https://www.history.com/news/doping-scandals-through-history-list) ([additional recent cases](https://www.theguardian.com/sport/drugs-in-sport)), but could a state restrict the use of FDA approved drugs for the purpose of performance enhancement above a nominally "natural" level within its borders? Or "plastic surgery" for cosmetic enhancement of a nominally non-deformed or injured patient, as opposed to reconstruction or correction? Or a form of "[body hacking](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Body_hacking)" or self-experimentation without existing federal regulations, for an example without a Supremacy Clause implication?

[States regulate physicians and surgeons, authorized to do so by the 10th amendment](https://physicians.uslegal.com/state-regulation-of-physicians/), but would an *intention*-based regulation overcome the federal supremacy of FDA approval for that drug? The closest existing example I know of (other than abortion or, hypothetically, alcohol) is [state laws targeting "pill-mills" (pdf)](https://www.cdc.gov/phlp/docs/menu-pmcr.pdf), but that's based on making prescribers jump through hoops, rather than specifying when a treatment can and can't be used.

FieldValue
text For example, [performance enhancing drug scandals are a perennial problem in sports](https://www.history.com/news/doping-scandals-through-history-list) ([additional recent cases](https://www.theguardian.com/sport/drugs-in-sport)), but could a state restrict the use of FDA approved drugs for the purpose of performance enhancement above a nominally "natural" level within its borders? Or "plastic surgery" for cosmetic enhancement of a nominally non-deformed or injured patient, as opposed to reconst…
label r/neutralpolitics
dataType post
communityName r/NeutralPolitics
datetime 2023-04-22
username_encoded Z0FBQUFBQm5LakwwS2FTUEJYalhaOHItYW5iZE4zT05yNGVYR3RNemw3c2d6WGQ0Y3Z4QzB6UHNVWmFMRkdRY1pPNVAzTVB1VDF3X21sNC00akRsZXhwdmFyWkRQQi1CS3U1RXBTbzZfVjVpLWM3MzR1T2I3RWs9
url_encoded Z0FBQUFBQm5Lak9EUDVtRHE1dDdYS1VaellHdG5VWDJWSUV5RzFqbkVhSGI2UGxtYXBmLS14WktGS3M2RE5YTTdZN3FNdUZpNkM2RW9nNG4zQXdSQVR3ckUtUlFPam9VSVYtMm9JTzJ0TjE5TWdFUHhXZ0dXanEwMjVheXRxYVU4Zl9rQVFzcmllbDlnUlVJSjBGVEpudzNDUUZ0UDgyRFR3TEpEbktmWjJwbGU1Q1ZJUzRtSGJlNHZHS0hIeFZERjlSV2E3aGtQeUdsMmsxR2FJVldielpEeXBxeHV2am1DUT09

Raw Record

{
  "text": "For example, [performance enhancing drug scandals are a perennial problem in sports](https://www.history.com/news/doping-scandals-through-history-list) ([additional recent cases](https://www.theguardian.com/sport/drugs-in-sport)), but could a state restrict the use of FDA approved drugs for the purpose of performance enhancement above a nominally \"natural\" level within its borders? Or \"plastic surgery\" for cosmetic enhancement of a nominally non-deformed or injured patient, as opposed to reconstruction or correction? Or a form of \"[body hacking](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Body_hacking)\" or self-experimentation without existing federal regulations, for an example without a Supremacy Clause implication?\n\n[States regulate physicians and surgeons, authorized to do so by the 10th amendment](https://physicians.uslegal.com/state-regulation-of-physicians/), but would an *intention*-based regulation overcome the federal supremacy of FDA approval for that drug? The closest existing example I know of (other than abortion or, hypothetically, alcohol) is [state laws targeting \"pill-mills\" (pdf)](https://www.cdc.gov/phlp/docs/menu-pmcr.pdf), but that's based on making prescribers jump through hoops, rather than specifying when a treatment can and can't be used.",
  "label": "r/neutralpolitics",
  "dataType": "post",
  "communityName": "r/NeutralPolitics",
  "datetime": "2023-04-22",
  "username_encoded": "Z0FBQUFBQm5LakwwS2FTUEJYalhaOHItYW5iZE4zT05yNGVYR3RNemw3c2d6WGQ0Y3Z4QzB6UHNVWmFMRkdRY1pPNVAzTVB1VDF3X21sNC00akRsZXhwdmFyWkRQQi1CS3U1RXBTbzZfVjVpLWM3MzR1T2I3RWs9",
  "url_encoded": "Z0FBQUFBQm5Lak9EUDVtRHE1dDdYS1VaellHdG5VWDJWSUV5RzFqbkVhSGI2UGxtYXBmLS14WktGS3M2RE5YTTdZN3FNdUZpNkM2RW9nNG4zQXdSQVR3ckUtUlFPam9VSVYtMm9JTzJ0TjE5TWdFUHhXZ0dXanEwMjVheXRxYVU4Zl9rQVFzcmllbDlnUlVJSjBGVEpudzNDUUZ0UDgyRFR3TEpEbktmWjJwbGU1Q1ZJUzRtSGJlNHZHS0hIeFZERjlSV2E3aGtQeUdsMmsxR2FJVldielpEeXBxeHV2am1DUT09"
}
Explore Dataset Explore Row

Entry Information